• Skip to main content

P A Downs

Christianity retold

  • About
  • Blog
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Form

Commentary

Commentary: The Lost Garnet Luke 15: 8-10

September 3, 2022 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

Image by starbright from Pixabay

The Lost Garnet is based on Luke 15: 8-10.

The Coin

I often find lost coins without searching for them. Coins nowadays are of so little value that I frequently find them on the streets, where someone’s dropped them. Far from searching frantically for them, people didn’t bother to stoop and pick them up.

In the UK, the highest value coin we have is £2. If a modern Jesus asked us if we’d search every nook and cranny of our homes for a £2 coin, the answer would be ‘errr… no?’ We’d have to be completely broke to be that desperate.

[Read more…] about Commentary: The Lost Garnet Luke 15: 8-10

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: Luke

Commentary: The Sourdough Starter-Matthew 13:33

August 20, 2022 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

Image by Thomas Bock from Pixabay

The Sourdough Starter is based on Matthew 13: 33

The original parable is only one verse long; this isn’t so much a retelling as an expansion.

Breadmaking

Nowadays, it’s a bit of a judgement call whether people will be familiar with breadmaking. The advantage of factory baked bread is that it makes a staple part of the diet cheap and readily available. A disadvantage is that it’s now possible to not have a clue how to make bread.

Jesus, however, could assume his audience would all be able to fill in the gaps. They’d know that the woman would need to add water to the flour/yeast mix. Then, they’d know that once the yeast was working through, the bread would rise. They’d also realise that only the risen dough would be baked into bread and just how much bread ‘three measures of flour’ would make (a lot). Even if they’d never personally baked a loaf of bread in their lives, they’d have seen it being done.

[Read more…] about Commentary: The Sourdough Starter-Matthew 13:33

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: Matthew

Comment: The Watchful House Sitter-Luke 12:35-38

August 6, 2022 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

Late night worker
Image by Ambady Sasi from Pixabay

The Watchful House Sitter is based on Luke 12: 35-38

Two Parables

This is an example of a parable that still exists in its two different forms. The version in Luke ends with the master rewarding his slaves by serving them a meal. But there’s another version in Mark (Mark 13: 32-37) which concentrates on the doorkeeper.

The most common explanation is that – in a world where ‘social media’ consisted of sending an expensive letter – Jesus varied his standard parables to make slightly different points. So Mark picked the version emphasising the loyal doorkeeper, watching through the night. Luke chose the version where the slaves working overtime being rewarded with their own party.

[Read more…] about Comment: The Watchful House Sitter-Luke 12:35-38

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: Luke, Mark

Commentary: The Friend at Midnight-Luke 11: 5-8

July 23, 2022 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

Image by Bruno /Germany from Pixabay

The Friend at Midnight is based on Luke 11: 5-8

Retelling

The first question is whether this parable need retelling. Even ten years ago, the idea of having to nip round to a neighbour to borrow some bread/sugar/coffee wasn’t that unusual. But nowadays, in my urban environment, getting food for an unexpected guest involves googling ’24 hour food delivery’. My friends would be justifiably annoyed if I decided to wake them up rather than just ordering a pizza. Or chicken wings, or a restaurant style meal…

[Read more…] about Commentary: The Friend at Midnight-Luke 11: 5-8

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: Luke

Commentary: The Good Israeli Settler: Luke 10: 30-36

June 18, 2022 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

Scenic Overlook by Ori/https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/

The Good Israeli Settler is based on Luke 10:30-36

Two Messages?

The parable of the Good Samaritan is frequently retold, mainly because only one of its two messages is popular today. Certainly, the UK pop culture understanding of the word ‘Samaritan’ is that it means ‘someone who helps people in need.’

It’s not a bad understanding to have – that The Good Samaritan tells us, ‘everyone in need is my neighbour.’ But it does skip over the Samaritan being from a hated group of people; that the Samaritan was the person your culture insists you’re supposed to hate.

[Read more…] about Commentary: The Good Israeli Settler: Luke 10: 30-36

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: Luke

Commentary: The Shrewd Lettings Agent (Luke 16:1-9)

May 21, 2022 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

Image by mohamed Hassan from Pixabay

The Shrewd Lettings Agent is based on Luke 16: 1-9

Introduction

This is probably the most confusing parable in the Gospels. It’s possible that the deep confusion is because Jesus was relying on a well known type of story in the ancient world; the wily servant outwits his master. In the context of the modern UK, this would be like using Robin Hood to make a point in a sermon. Everyone knows Robin Hood will rob the rich and give to the poor – and we wouldn’t assume that the preacher was telling everyone to go out and rob random rich people. We’d look for: ‘What is it in this story of Robin Hood that tells us about God?’

[Read more…] about Commentary: The Shrewd Lettings Agent (Luke 16:1-9)

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: Luke

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 7
  • Go to Next Page »

Copyright © 2025 · Author Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in