• Skip to main content

P A Downs

Christianity retold

  • About
  • Blog
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Form

Commentary

Commentary: The Dogs and Cats (Matt. 25:31-46)

August 19, 2023 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

Image by DreamDigitalArtist at Pixabay

The Dogs and the Cats is based on Matthew 25: 31-46.

The Sheep and the Goats

One sign a parable might need retelling is that its original allusions are now flying right over everyone’s head. It’s not that we don’t understand the basics of the parable. But why sheep? Why goats?

To people in the modern West, there’s nothing obviously good about sheep. There’s also nothing bad about goats. If anything, people use ‘sheep’ or ‘sheeple’ as an insult and admire the goat for its independent nature.

Symbolism

In the Bible, the House of Israel is often linked with ‘sheep’. But being scattered ‘like sheep without a shepherd‘ was not a compliment. Domesticated sheep without a shepherd are in trouble. In Matthew 9:36, Matthew describes Jesus as feeling sorry for the crowds because they are ‘like sheep without a shepherd’.

[Read more…] about Commentary: The Dogs and Cats (Matt. 25:31-46)

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: Matthew

The Dogs and the Cats (Matthew 25: 31-46)

July 1, 2023 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

Image by DreamDigitalArtist at Pixabay

The Dogs and the Cats is based on Matthew 25: 31-46.

When the Son of Man comes in glory, angels will be with him. He’ll sit on his Judges’ Bench and he’ll separate people one from another, like an animal shelter would separate the dogs and the cats. Dogs on the right, cats on the left.

[Read more…] about The Dogs and the Cats (Matthew 25: 31-46)

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: Matthew

Commentary: The Two Debtors (Luke 7: 41-43)

June 24, 2023 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

The Two Debtors is based on Luke 7: 41-43

Does This Parable Need Retelling?

I nearly put this parable in Parables That Don’t Need Retelling, so – no, not necessarily. Money lenders and debt still exist, as I mentioned in the commentary on The Unforgiving Debtor. But the way we handle that debt has changed enough that we might need to retell this parable.

[Read more…] about Commentary: The Two Debtors (Luke 7: 41-43)

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: Luke

Commentary: The Big Parade (Matthew 25:1-12)

June 10, 2023 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

Image by Vlad Vasnetsov from Pixabay

The Big Parade is based on Matthew 25:1-12

Alternative Possibilities

This was one of the first parables I ever saw ‘retold’ – a minor updating for children, replacing the oil lamps with more modern torches (‘flashlights’ in US English). The oil that was carried by five of the girls became spare batteries.

[Read more…] about Commentary: The Big Parade (Matthew 25:1-12)

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: Matthew

Commentary: Counting the Cost (Luke 14:28-33)

May 27, 2023 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

Image by Alexa from Pixabay

Counting the Cost is based on Luke 14: 28-33

Two Mini-Parables

This section of Luke’s Gospel comprises two mini-parables. We don’t know whether Jesus always told them together, or whether he sometimes split them up. Both are about the cost of discipleship – one about losing all our money, the other about losing our lives, families and homes.

[Read more…] about Commentary: Counting the Cost (Luke 14:28-33)

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: Luke

Commentary: The Teacher’s Voice (John 10: 1-5)

April 15, 2023 by P A Downs Leave a Comment

Image by Marjan from Pixabay

The Teacher’s Voice is based on John 10:1-5

The Image of the Shepherd

The country I live in has been shaped by over a thousand years of Christianity. One result is that the image of the shepherd-leader is very familiar. Another is that – even in an urban environment – the image of the shepherd is very popular. TV programmes about shepherds, for example, get reasonable viewing figures.

That creates a problem for parables about shepherds, because shepherding in the modern UK is very different from shepherding in Judea and Galilee. In the UK, like much of Northern Europe, pasture is easy to find. Like much of Northern Europe, wool was historically a major (and very profitable) industry. The Northern European shepherd doesn’t have to search for pasture; instead, they walk behind the flock, driving them in the direction they need to go.

[Read more…] about Commentary: The Teacher’s Voice (John 10: 1-5)

Filed Under: Commentary, New Testament, Parable Tagged With: John, Matthew

  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 7
  • Go to Next Page »

Copyright © 2025 · Author Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in